Skip to main content

The controversy surrounding Spotify's divisive "Discovery Mode" has not subsided since the streaming giant announced the initiative in late 2020. The feature offers some artists and record labels a chance to boost the rankings of their music in the platform's playlisting algorithm—a crucial tool for exposure—in exchange for a reduced royalty rate.

Considering the notion that royalties are already extremely low—fractions of one penny per stream, to be exact—the contentious "Discovery Mode" feature seems to make things even more difficult for artists hoping to get their music in front of as many people possible while earning fair compensation for their works.

"Discovery Mode" has now come to the attention of Representative Jerrold Nadler (chairman of the House Judiciary Committee) and Representative Hank Johnson Jr. (chairman of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, and the Internet) who recently penned a letter to Spotify founder Daniel Ek to probe the issue.

"We write regarding the new 'Discovery Mode' feature that Spotify has begun pilot testing on its Radio and Autoplay features," reads the letter, which was shared by THR. "Although public details are limited, Discovery Mode appears to allow artists and record labels to identify particular songs that they would like to prioritize in Spotify’s algorithmic recommendations in exchange for agreeing to be paid a lower, 'promotional' royalty rate for those prioritized streams. This may set in motion a 'race to the bottom' in which artists and labels feel compelled to accept lower royalties as a necessary way to break through an extremely crowded and competitive music environment."

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

zedd

Zedd Reveals One-Time-Only "Clarity" Ten Year Anniversary Performance in San Francisco

At the special event, Zedd will play every track from his 2012 debut album.

Movement

Set Times and Special GRiZ Performance Announced for Movement 2022

The Detroit festival will feature performances from Jeff Mills, The Martinez Brothers, Carl Craig, Maya Jane Coles, Flying Lotus, Chris Lake, and more.

Infographic depicting what goes into Spotify's personalized recommendations.

Infographic depicting what goes into Spotify's personalized recommendations.

"At a time when the global pandemic has devastated incomes for musicians and other performers, without a clear path back to pre-pandemic levels, any plan that could ultimately lead to further cut pay for working artists and ultimately potentially less consumer choice raises significant policy issues," Nadler and Johnson Jr. continue. "This is particularly true under Spotify’s current model, where artists’ returns are already low, with Spotify reporting to pay artists less than a cent per song streamed (estimated in the $.003 to $.005 range) and Spotify has challenged an administrative ruling setting a higher royalty rate for songwriters. Core copyright industries like music play an integral role in the U.S. economy, and the vitality of the industry is undermined when artists’ hard work is undervalued. Such a race to the bottom threatens to weaken the core goal of copyright and intellectual property—incentivizing creativity by offering a fair return on one’s work."

Since Spotify is a Swedish company, the company may ultimately have little to worry about in terms of the probe from Congress. However, the House Judiciary Committee's letter could galvanize the company to provide clarity on some timely concerns surrounding royalty rates, the measurement of the controversial feature's success, and what Spotify's plans are to prevent a scenario wherein artists receive less money for seemingly fruitless promotion opportunities.

Related

spotify

Open Letter From Congress Rips Spotify's Controversial Discovery Mode, Seeks Financial Transparency

Congressional leaders are requesting Spotify release a monthly report of all the content included in its promotional Discovery Mode feature.

spotify

Wolf In Sheep's Clothing? How Spotify's Discovery Mode May Harm Artists and Listeners

The Discovery Mode feature feeds audiences the music that saves Spotify the most money, contradicting its original value proposition.

Spotify money

Here's How Much Each Music Streaming Platform Pays Per Stream

Aggregate data was collected by The Trichordist.

apple-vs-spotify

Apple Music Jabs Spotify With Controversial Newsletter: Read the Full Statement

"We believe in the value of music and paying creators fairly for their work."

BlogPost_2__3_

Spotify for Artists Introduces Canvas Designer Marketplace via SoundBetter

Artists now have more custom options for Canvas video creation than ever before.

Spotify money

Spotify Launches "Loud & Clear" Initiative Aimed At Increasing Transparency

Spotify has responded to arguments from critics with a new data-driven multimedia venture.

Keyboard

Secretive White Noise Spammers are Making a Killing on Spotify—Here's How

Obscure "artists" like White Noise Baby Sleep rack up millions of streams daily.

Avicii

New Study Reveals Avicii's "Wake Me Up" As the Most Valuable Song From Sweden

The study reveals the most valuable song from every country, including many songs from electronic artists.