After two years, a judge has finally put an end to the lengthy legal battle between dance music producers ARTY and Marshmello.

The copyright suit was filed in May 2019 after ARTY claimed that Mello had stolen the melody of his 2014 remix of OneRepublic's "I Lived," subsequently recycling it for the 2018 hit single "Happier" with Bastille. Dan Smith, the British band's frontman, was also named in the copyright suit along with producer Steve Mac. 

The decision came down on Thursday in favor of Marshmello, Smith and Mac, with California US District Judge Philip S. Gutierrez ruling that ARTY had no grounds to sue under the terms of his "I Lived" contract with OneRepublic. “I acknowledge and agree that the services rendered (or to be rendered) by Remixer hereunder do not entitle Remixer or me to any ownership or financial interest in the underlying musical composition," the signed agreement stated. 

According to Gutierrez, the "underlying musical composition" in question included not only the original version of "I Lived," but also ARTY's remix. This opinion sets the legal precedent that remixers do not own the rights to their work when it comes to copyright infringements. 

Recommended Articles

Deorro

Deorro Taps J Balvin Collaborator Jeon for Spicy New Hip-Shaker, "Rumba"

Packed with Cumbia-inspired flavor, the track is the fifth to be released ahead of Deorro's debut Latin album.

kygo

Kygo's Palm Tree Crew to Host Music Festival With Zedd, Gryffin, More

Kygo is bringing the star power for the first-ever Palm Tree Music Festival.

Pauline Herr

"100% Authentic": Pauline Herr's Electric New EP Is Self-Sung, Written, Produced and Mixed

"All I really want is to connect with people by showing them my heart, while being as transparent and vulnerable as possible."

On the contrary, a five year battle between Marvin Gaye's estate and Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams for "Blurred Lines" saw ripple effects in the opposite direction after a jury ruled in favor of Gaye's estate and, as a result, songwriters in general. The controversial decision awarded Gaye's family millions of dollars in damages for copyright infringement, stating Thicke and Williams had stolen the style and feel of Gaye's 1977 song "Got To Give It Up." 

Following the ruling, artists including Taylor Swift and Ed Sheeran began affording songwriting credits to artists whose past work sounded similar to their new tracks. In his own suit, ARTY was represented by the lawyer for Gaye's estate in the "Blurred Lines" case, Richard Busch, according to Variety.

You can read the full court ruling here courtesy of The Hollywood Reporter's Eriq Gardner.

Related

A side-by-side photo of DJ/producers ARTY and Marshmello (left to right).

ARTY is Suing Marshmello and Dan Smith of Bastille for Copyright Infringement

ARTY alleges that the melody in "Happier" by Marshmello and Bastille was lifted from his remix of "I Lived" by OneRepublic.

A side-by-side photo of DJ/producers ARTY and Marshmello (left to right).

Marshmello Calls Lawsuit by ARTY "an Exercise in Futility"

Marshmello is aiming to have ARTY's lawsuit thrown out of court.

Marshmello

"Happier" by Marshmello and Bastille Reaches 50 Straight Weeks at #1 on Billboard Charts

Marshmello and Bastille's track "Happier" continues its reign atop the Hot Dance/Electronic Songs chart.

deadmau5

High-Profile Music Publishers Have Filed a Lawsuit Against Roblox for Copyright Infringement

Like its rising tech counterparts, Roblox has found themselves in hot water over allegations of enabling users to stream unlicensed music.

Glam metal band Steel Panther and EDM DJ/producer Marshmello in a split-screen image.

Steel Panther Members React to Marshmello and Bastille's "Happier"

Steel Panther's The World of Music Episode #4 highlights music from EDM's favorite masked producer.

Bastille's Dan Smith appearing alongside Marshmello on the Season 15 Finale of The Voice.

Marshmello and Bastille Perform "Happier" on The Voice Finale

The Voice had two very special guests for its Season 15 finale.